Click here to listen to my guest appearance on KCRW’s To the Point, addressing the exoneration movement, and also the excessively punitive turn in our criminal justice system.
Click here to read my op-ed in the New York Times, addressing the absence of a plea bargaining effort in the case of Adnan Syed, the subject of the popular podcast, Serial.
How must a defendant effectively object to facts in the presentence report (PSR)? With “specificity and clarity,” the Eighth Circuit repeats in United States v. Pepper, issued on March 20, 2014 (published), so as “to put the Government on notice of the challenged facts.” In other words, it is not enough for the defense lawyer […]
The post Eighth Circuit Affirms Sentences Based on Uncontested Facts in the PSR appeared first on .
The fabulous Historyapolis Project, run by Kirsten Delagard, Scholar-in-Residence in the Department of History at Augsburg College, is running a series of blog entries this women’s history month showcasing notable Minneapolis women. On March 13, 2014, the Project ran this entry by JaneAnne Murray on civil rights lawyer and activist, Lena Olive Smith.
The post Historyapolis Publishes Blog Entry about Lena Olive Smith appeared first on .
In Sex Abuse Case, Eighth Circuit Affirms Exclusion of Prior Sex Abuse Conviction to Avoid Confusion
The headline of this post may be misleading, since it implies a rare ruling excluding a defendant’s prior conviction similar to the charge at issue. In United States v. Patrick Brown Thunder, issued on March 12, 2014 (published), however, at issue was not a prior conviction of the defendant, but a prior conviction of someone […]
The post In Sex Abuse Case, Eighth Circuit Affirms Exclusion of Prior Sex Abuse Conviction to Avoid Confusion appeared first on .
Eighth Circuit Affirms Imposition of Lengthy Sentences Despite Erroneous Estimates in Plea Agreements
Time and again, the issue on appeal involves a defendant whose presentence report estimated a guideline range far higher than that in his plea agreement – sometimes triggering three-strikes laws and mandatory minimum sentences. Two recent cases, United States v. Ruacho, issued on March 11, 2014 (published), and United Haubrich, issued on March 3, 2014 […]
The post Eighth Circuit Affirms Imposition of Lengthy Sentences Despite Erroneous Estimates in Plea Agreements appeared first on .
Is this a bar exam question? Spot the bases for suppression in the following thumbnail description from the Eighth Circuit’s website of United States v. Douglas, issued on March 11, 2014 (published): District court did not err in denying defendant’s motion to suppress a shotgun found hidden in a trash bag in an abandoned refrigerator […]
The post Eighth Circuit Affirms Denial of Suppression Involving Abandoned Property appeared first on .
In a cautionary tale, Raymond Cortez was convicted at trial based in part (or maybe wholly) on a factual stipulation contained in a written plea agreement he had entered into with the government, but which he later rejected. In the plea agreement, Cortez “agree[d] this stipulation [could] be used against [him] at any time in […]
The post Eighth Circuit Affirms Trial Conviction Where Defendant’s Plea Stipulation Entered Into Evidence appeared first on .
In United States v. Vore, issued on March 4, 2014 (published), the Eighth Circuit affirmed the district court’s denial of the defense request for a “mere presence” instruction. This instruction reminds the jury that a defendant’s mere presence near contraband or those engaged in criminal activity is not enough to establish knowledge or control of […]
The post Eighth Circuit Affirms Denial of “Mere Presence” Instruction appeared first on .
Is a defendant denying responsibility when he challenges a guideline enhancement in his presentence report? The Eighth Circuit leaves that important question open in United States v. Bowers, issued on March 4, 2014 (published). But it’s a complex question that raises competing principles: accuracy in sentencing, the enforceability of plea agreements, and the burdens of […]
The post Eighth Circuit Affirms Sentencing Enhancement Not Advocated by Government appeared first on .